Woman Sent to Jail for Asking for Officer’s Business Card Wins Her Lawsuit

 

 Shei'Meka Newmann

by Dr. Boyce Watkins, Your Black WorldScholarship in Action 

Shei’Meka Newmann just won a major victory for herself and for everyone who has ever been victimized by the system. The 33-year old Oregon woman won an $82,000 judgment against the Portland police after she was arrested for simply asking for a police officer’s business card.

The incident occurred in February, 2009 when the woman noticed a questionable and seemingly brutal arrest of a fellow citizen. This led her to walk up to one of the officers, Aaron Dauchy, who’d grabbed a 29-year old black man off a train and handcuffed him on the ground. When Ms. Newmann asked why the officer was dealing with the man with so much force, he told her to mind her own business.

Ms. Newmann didn’t stop at that point. She then went to Dauchy’s partner, Officer Jim Sandvik, to ask for a business card. But Sandvik refused to give her the card and took her ID. When she stepped forward to read the officer’s name on his badge, he hit her in the chest and handcuffed her. She was then taken to jail and released the next day without her money, her cell phone or even her shoe laces.

Sandvik attempted to convince the jury that Ms. Newmann was yelling and belligerent. He also said that she approached him from behind while he was dealing with four drunken men. But jurors were unconvinced after watching the surveillance video, which showed the officers to be untruthful in their version of the facts.

One officer, Paul Valdez, actually testified that Ms. Newmann was polite and respectful to the officers when she approached them. He also said that she didn’t interfere with their duties in the way they described.

Newmann said that she wasn’t going to sue at first, but decided to do so because she encourages the students she mentors to stand up for what is right. She grew up in several foster homes as a child and then graduated from high school with a 3.8 GPA. She has also been a foster mom herself and has received awards for outstanding volunteer work.

Reading the story about Shei’Meka Newmann made me proud. When citizens stand up in the face of tyranny, it makes America a little bit better every time. Additionally, Newmann’s experience is incredibly common, as police officers are known for abusing their authority. As the son of a police officer, I can testify that many officers do not like their power to be questioned, putting law-abiding citizens in harm’s way for simply asking the wrong question.

Americans must work to protect our civil liberties from overzealous police. In a nation that has fallen in love with mass incarceration, each of us finds our freedom at risk, because one tiny incident can cause us to have an experience as humiliating as the one endured by Ms. Newmann. There is no reason that this good woman and upstanding citizen should have been brutalized, arrested and sent to jail. The department was lucky to only have to pay $82,000 for nearly ruining this woman’s life by giving her a criminal record.

On a brighter note, it should be recognized that it was the testimony of an honest police officer, Paul Valdez, that helped Ms. Newmann convince the jury to believe her side of the story. This shows that not every police officer is corrupt and many of them are seeking to do the right thing. The world can always find a use for ethical police officers, and they should serve as righteous partners in our quest to end police abuse everywhere.

Dr. Boyce Watkins is the founder of the Your Black World Coalition.  To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered to your email, please click here.

Advertisements

20 Comments

Filed under African Americans

20 responses to “Woman Sent to Jail for Asking for Officer’s Business Card Wins Her Lawsuit

  1. Pingback: Woman Sent to Jail for Asking for Officer’s Business Card Wins Her Lawsuit « Black College Students

  2. Pingback: Woman Sent to Jail for Asking for Officer’s Business Card Wins Her Lawsuit « Black Gossip for Black America, Black Celebrities included

  3. Pingback: Woman Sent to Jail for Asking for Officer’s Business Card Wins Her Lawsuit | Black Men in Prison

  4. Pingback: Woman Sent to Jail for Asking for Officer’s Business Card Wins Her Lawsuit « Black News in the black community

  5. Rose

    Good for her, she showed them they cannot always treat us any kind of way and think we will not retaliate. We need to learn from her experience and stand up for ourselves as much as possible. Hit the system where it hurts, in the pocket.

  6. David

    And police officers should be held accountable for offering each other “professional courtesies” such as flash a badge and speed all you want, both on and off duty, without cause, just because you are a police officer. Police should be setting the example for the community, not violating it.

  7. Pingback: Woman Sent to Jail for Asking for Officer’s Business Card Wins Her Lawsuit « youngblacknews.com

  8. Pingback: Woman Sent to Jail for Asking for Officer’s Business Card Wins Her Lawsuit | Scholarship in Action

  9. Pingback: Woman Sent to Jail for Asking for Officer’s Business Card Wins Her Lawsuit « WhitmanSchoolofManagement.com

  10. Pingback: Woman Wins Lawsuit Against Police: Was Arrested for Asking for a Business Card « Scholarship in Action, Dr Boyce Watkins, Syracuse University

  11. Pingback: Woman Wins Lawsuit Against Police: Was Arrested for Asking for a Business Card « Black Politics for African Americans

  12. Pingback: Woman Wins Lawsuit Against Police: Was Arrested for Asking for a Business Card « ScholarshipInAction.com

  13. Pingback: Woman Wins Lawsuit Against Police: Was Arrested for Asking for a Business Card « Black Politics for Black America

  14. Pingback: Woman Wins Lawsuit Against Police: Was Arrested for Asking for a Business Card « Black Politics, Black Voters, Black People

  15. This is an example of stories that we need to hear as we strive to be honest law-abiding citizens and not victims of a system that is designed to protect us. As with some systems–there are those who misrepresent them like the two officers in question. Thank God for those like Officer Valdez who restores our faith in them.

  16. Shahid Raki

    Where did these two dharacters come from? A citizen has the right to ask a police officer a simple question, so long as they do not impede their act of subduing a person, if that person is subdued like they are human being and not an animal. There are some people who should not get into Law Enforcement because they don’t know what they are supposed to be doing. There have been too many individuals who have been shown to have used excessive force when apprehending a suspect. Maybe they’ll think twice before they try to do something like this again.

  17. Hooray, Hooray, this warms my heart. I love courageous people.

  18. love this!!! I love that she didn’t let how she grew affect her life!

  19. Alberta K. Wilson

    Thank God for Officer Valdez whose courageous act might have been the deciding factor in this case. I wonder what the verdict would have been had he not come forward and told what he observed? We need more indivvuals like this sister and officer Valdez.

  20. Amanda

    I need your guidance. Had a similar experience… please help.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s